I leave that between him and God. I guess the bishop is satisfied with the interview. I am not sure I should get involved in it. The short story is this. In 2005 my husband left the church to attend the local Calvary Chapel, was baptized (as far as I know this wasn't considered to be a church joining deal), & started coming to church with us in November 2006. The bishop is aware of all the details and I guess whatever is said during the interview is satisfactory for him. My husband went on his own (without my knowledge) to ask for his TR again. When the bishop told me a just about fell out of my chair. The reason for the bishop telling me was that he wanted to renew mine (even though I still had a year left on it) so that it would be like a fresh start for both my husband and I. VR