Jonathon, I'm a convert that studied many denominations and spent hours in meetings with ministers of churches discussing the restored gospel. The Holy Spirit testified to me of the truth and I asked to be baptized a Latter-Day Saint. I know what it's like to have many philosophies and religious beliefs contending for what is true in your heart, but when the Holy Spirit testified of the truth, it no longer mattered who I had spoken with or what I had read. The power of the Lord to change men's hearts is greater than all the philosophies of men put together. Reading and analyzing is good, but what we need to give us faith and testimony is a personal touch from the Divine. Every person is promised that if they will exercise the smallest amount of faith, sincerely ask for the forgiveness of their sins, and live the teachings of Christ, we will receive that touch. What you've recognized is the Spirit of the Lord calling you back. I believe with all my heart that's what the Lord wants. If I can be of any help to you in that regard, don't hesitate to message me.