Hi every one. I found this thread in a google search and figured I might weigh in on this subject matter. Even though the thread is rather old I thought why not.
First of all I am LDS and have been one for a long time. Second of all I am a Male to Female member.
Here are my core beliefs. The church or any church for that matter has the right to associate with any one they so choose...or reject who ever they choose.
God does not make mistakes. However this is an imperfect world and is part of the test. Nature by design is not perfect and nor is man. In todays world there are all kinds of chemicals and drugs and other hormones in the environment. Both natural and man made.
My condition was the result of a man made drug. It was something given to my mother during the pregnancy that caused this to happen. I will not give the drugs name for privacy reasons that some of you may not understand but I have my reasons. However I can tell you this it caused what is called Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome. In other words I was not masculinizing normally.
My journey in this life is certainly a trial. My mother knew from a very early age that there was something terribly wrong with my gender expression and tried every thing in her power to convince me to be more male like. From personal threats to condemnation from God above and even excommunication from the church.
It forced me into her desired role. Un-happiness ensued and some life altering mistakes were made as a result. When she finally came clean with what was really going on later in my life things started to make sense.
I even came out to the church at one point. First speaking to my new Bishop and he scratched his head and deferred me to the stake presidency. I met with him for a year. In that entire time I did not experience any of the prophetic condemnation my mother told me would happen. In fact I was met with love and concern for my well being.
Now I am not inclined to reveal what or if I hold callings or what I was allowed to do in church. But suffice it to say that these situations are handled in very individual ways. I had 3 bishops who knew my situation and of the 3 only one was perplexed. The other two were accepting and the stake president became like a Dad to me.
My feeling is this, the church is aware that cases like mine exist. But they are performing a balancing act. The general membership is not ready to accept some like me with open arms. Had this occurred in an old ward where every one thought of me as an effeminate male before, I can guarantee there would have been a problem. The bishop in that case may have had to dismiss me or excommunicate me for the greater good. I would not want to be the bishop having to deal with the sisters of the church knocking down my door.
As you can probably gather I look and sound female. There is nothing garish about my appearance and if any of you encountered me at church not a single one of you would know the difference.
For me, this purely a matter of identity and I am square with heavenly father and if asked temple questions today I would be able to affirm yes that I am in good standing.
Now, am I allowed to go to the temple? The answer is no. I feel that this is a way to keep the church safe because what if some one found out and made a fiasco out of it? One day I will be able to go to the temple. I was affirmed of that in a blessing...but not now. And some thing else was told to me in a blessing that I hold close to my heart and has helped me on this journey.
Being like this sure has given me a unique way of observing life.
The Lord has different plans for me.