hey dory...your post sounds almost EXACTLY what i'm going thru w/ my spouse...except I'M the more 'religious' one [based on my level of enthusiasm for church participation, study, and all ]... people [family, etc.] told me i'm wrong, or told me to read this or that - things that will TELL me what is RIGHT...i KNOW what is ideal... my feelings, however, have brought me to a place that is LESS than ideal... i've learned over the years that i must ultimately trust MYSELF...when i was taught by the missionaries they did not say to believe them or anything they teach, or anything i read...but to PRAY & get my own answers...the lord asks, 'what do u WANT?'... and says to 'study it out in YOUR OWN MIND'...of course, divorce is not GOOD...divorce is not IDEAL...divorce is the last thing i EVER wanted...[everyone in my immediate family has been divorced...except me]...i wanted to be the ONE...the EXAMPLE... the SUCCESS story like paul newman and his wife...or brother & sister hinckley...or like so many others who make the grade...as one bishop's wife told me...'either choice will be hard'...whether you choose to stick it out , or choose to go it alone...you will have tough times...my spouse and i are both in personal church counseling for what has transpired over the years to bring us to this point ... right and wrong is not always black and white...as i experience things i NEVER wanted to experience in life i discover about 14 shades of gray...i tell people [who think things are always black and white - typically younger people] 'talk to me in 20 years...' i love the church; i participate; i attend the temple; AND i feel i cannot continue in the marriage i agreed to @ age 17 [i'm 47 now - and going thru this midlife REEVALUATION, i've found that there ARE exceptions to every rule...[remember, 'thou shalt not kill'...but nephi was commanded to take the life of laban?...abraham experienced this same dilemma...and i know people will say that my dilemma has nothing to do with these stories...but as we 'liken the scriptures unto ourselves' we will sometimes have the same EXTREMELY hard 'figuring out to do'...]...i always hated when a couple in church got divorced-i felt like they were weakening the resolve of 'the rest of us' to hang in there...and now i've become one of them...i don't know what else to say...except that i WISH ALL marriages lasted forever, and everyone lived after the manner of happiness equally yoked with their best friend...the lord wishes the same thing & teaches us this ideal; but i HAVE to follow the dictates of my own conscience AND let the consequence follow: good or bad...i know that even the 'very elect' can be deceived in the 'last days' and all i can do is the best i can according to the hand i've been dealt...and continue to believe the lord will not leave me or forsake me...everyone else may, but the lord, NEVER....