mikbone Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 (edited) A B Edited November 29, 2018 by mikbone Quote
Emmanuel Goldstein Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 Why would Adam and Eve look traumatized? GMAB Quote
mikbone Posted November 29, 2018 Author Report Posted November 29, 2018 (edited) 51 minutes ago, Emmanuel Goldstein said: Why would Adam and Eve look traumatized? GMAB Maybe because they just took an innocent life. I wonder if Abraham had a traumatized appearance after he set his mind to sacrifice Isaac... Do we ever take the sacrament and feel ashamed or traumatized.... Edited November 29, 2018 by mikbone Quote
Emmanuel Goldstein Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 (edited) 10 hours ago, mikbone said: Maybe because they just took an innocent life. I wonder if Abraham had a traumatized appearance after he set his mind to sacrifice Isaac... Do we ever take the sacrament and feel ashamed or traumatized.... It is food not a person. GMAB Also, why would he have an Iron knife. He would have used stone. There is no evidence that people even had bronze until about the time of Abraham. Edited November 29, 2018 by Emmanuel Goldstein Quote
CV75 Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 9 hours ago, mikbone said: Maybe because they just took an innocent life. I wonder if Abraham had a traumatized appearance after he set his mind to sacrifice Isaac... Do we ever take the sacrament and feel ashamed or traumatized.... Those are some of the feelings we have, ideally in an inspired (godly) sense of course. The sacrament hymns seem to capture many of the feelings we can have, and teach us along with scripture the feelings we can have. Thank you for mentioning these two, because they are part of the repentant heart and lead to a broken heart, contrite spirit. I used to wonder why stake leaders would look so miserable up there on the stand while partaking of the sacrament, while I felt so forgiven and recommitted, but all these feelings have their place and I'm sure they had more positive feelings too; all depends of the day we're having or the phase of life we're in. Many beneficial feelings may accompany our ponderings during the sacrament, and by using the symbols for their intended purposes, as the sacrificial lambs were. I anticipate the animal sacrifices to be restored someday. By the gifts of the Spirit we do not need to literally slaughter, or almost slaughter, an innocent lamb or child to generate these feelings about our role in sacrificing His innocent life, if we pray for and receive charity in all the experiences our mundane lives afford us (I thin that is why Moroni emphasized this principle so much). One man's trauma is another man's "meh." mikbone 1 Quote
Emmanuel Goldstein Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 This is what I think of when I think "Lamb of God": Colirio, SilentOne, Midwest LDS and 1 other 3 1 Quote
Traveler Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 I think a lot has been lost to a people and society that purchases it's food at the local super market and the only animals they deal with (care for) are beloved pets. The Traveler Quote
Emmanuel Goldstein Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 4 minutes ago, Traveler said: I think a lot has been lost to a people and society that purchases it's food at the local super market and the only animals they deal with (care for) are beloved pets. The Traveler Yep, you should kill what you eat and eat what you kill. Quote
Traveler Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 1 minute ago, Emmanuel Goldstein said: Yep, you should kill what you eat and eat what you kill. Do you? The Traveler Quote
CV75 Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 8 minutes ago, Emmanuel Goldstein said: Yep, you should kill what you eat and eat what you kill. I kill what tries to eat me. zil and SilentOne 2 Quote
Emmanuel Goldstein Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 2 hours ago, Traveler said: Do you? The Traveler Nope, wish I did not live in a city so I could though. Quote
mordorbund Posted November 29, 2018 Report Posted November 29, 2018 1 hour ago, Emmanuel Goldstein said: Nope, wish I did not live in a city so I could though. http://airfielddiners.com/skidmarkscafe/ ? Quote
mikbone Posted November 30, 2018 Author Report Posted November 30, 2018 8 hours ago, Emmanuel Goldstein said: It is food not a person. GMAB Also, why would he have an Iron knife. He would have used stone. There is no evidence that people even had bronze until about the time of Abraham. Well, glad you asked. There are some of us Latter-Day Saints that believe that Adam and Even grew up in the Garden of Eden from birth through adulthood, with Godly parents... And I pretty much feel like it is disingenuous to assume that Adam used a stone knife. Adam was an extremely intelligent and an inspired son of God. We see that Nephi and the Brother of Jared were directed by the lord to make metal tools to fashion their ships (1 Nephi 17:9, Ether 2:1). I think that it was much more likely that Adam was taught many skills including metal working, carpentry, etc... The Lord taught Adam how to read and write, so he at least learned how to make paper or vellum and a pen. I'm not sure why any LDS would assume that Adam lived as a unenlightened caveman... It is much more likely that Adam, as taught by God, was an artisan craftsman of many skills. Likely as his children began to turn away from the Lord they became a dark, loathsome, and slothful people who lost the skills of their enlightened forefathers. As to the Lamb being food and not a person. Yes this is true. But try to take a different perspective. While in the Garden of Eden, Adam and Eve never killed or observed death. Adam named all the animals and interacted with them. Adam was charged with keeping and dressing the Garden. After the fall, the Lord required Adam to kill his first animal in order to start the practice and commandment of burnt offerings. I'm sure that Adam's experience was not as bad as Abraham's (commanded to offer up his son Isaac), but this requirement was contrary to everything that Adam had previously been taught. Adam recognized that his actions (transgression via partaking the ToKoG&E) produced the consequences that required sacrifice of the Lamb. I testify, that when Adam killed that first burnt offering, that his spirit was broken and his heart was contrite. I also believe that after Adam & Eve offered up these sacrifices, that they were directed under God's instruction to construct the first pair of garments... (Moses 4:27). You see, whenever Adam placed his garments of consumed the flesh of the animals, he recalled that his actions required the sacrifice of others. And eventually he was taught the gospel and learned that the sacrifice of animals was a similitude of the sacrifice of the only begotten... Burnt offerings, I assume were taken from the sons of God because we no longer offered sacrifice with a broken heart and a contrite spirit. We are consumers of the world and believe that we deserve the bounties of the Earth without consequence. Have you ever placed your garments and wondered what it was like for Adam and Eve to produce their own garments? Have you ever eaten a burger and thanked the Lord for all that He has provided us with? We don't have to wait until Sunday for the bread and water to muster up feelings of thankfulness. And I find it interesting how some people can spend the sacrament thinking about themselves and their shortcomings, when in reality we should actually be thinking about Jesus Christ and what He did for us... Quote
CV75 Posted November 30, 2018 Report Posted November 30, 2018 46 minutes ago, mikbone said: Well, glad you asked. There are some of us Latter-Day Saints that believe that Adam and Even grew up in the Garden of Eden from birth through adulthood, with Godly parents... And I pretty much feel like it is disingenuous to assume that Adam used a stone knife. Adam was an extremely intelligent and an inspired son of God. We see that Nephi and the Brother of Jared were directed by the lord to make metal tools to fashion their ships (1 Nephi 17:9, Ether 2:1). I think that it was much more likely that Adam was taught many skills including metal working, carpentry, etc... The Lord taught Adam how to read and write, so he at least learned how to make paper or vellum and a pen. I'm not sure why any LDS would assume that Adam lived as a unenlightened caveman... It is much more likely that Adam, as taught by God, was an artisan craftsman of many skills. Likely as his children began to turn away from the Lord they became a dark, loathsome, and slothful people who lost the skills of their enlightened forefathers. As to the Lamb being food and not a person. Yes this is true. But try to take a different perspective. While in the Garden of Eden, Adam and Eve never killed or observed death. Adam named all the animals and interacted with them. Adam was charged with keeping and dressing the Garden. After the fall, the Lord required Adam to kill his first animal in order to start the practice and commandment of burnt offerings. I'm sure that Adam's experience was not as bad as Abraham's (commanded to offer up his son Isaac), but this requirement was contrary to everything that Adam had previously been taught. Adam recognized that his actions (transgression via partaking the ToKoG&E) produced the consequences that required sacrifice of the Lamb. I testify, that when Adam killed that first burnt offering, that his spirit was broken and his heart was contrite. I also believe that after Adam & Eve offered up these sacrifices, that they were directed under God's instruction to construct the first pair of garments... (Moses 4:27). You see, whenever Adam placed his garments of consumed the flesh of the animals, he recalled that his actions required the sacrifice of others. And eventually he was taught the gospel and learned that the sacrifice of animals was a similitude of the sacrifice of the only begotten... Burnt offerings, I assume were taken from the sons of God because we no longer offered sacrifice with a broken heart and a contrite spirit. We are consumers of the world and believe that we deserve the bounties of the Earth without consequence. Have you ever placed your garments and wondered what it was like for Adam and Eve to produce their own garments? Have you ever eaten a burger and thanked the Lord for all that He has provided us with? We don't have to wait until Sunday for the bread and water to muster up feelings of thankfulness. And I find it interesting how some people can spend the sacrament thinking about themselves and their shortcomings, when in reality we should actually be thinking about Jesus Christ and what He did for us... Just a couple of tips: 1) testimony ends the exchange of ideas, which is what I find valuable about "Gospel Discussion"; 2) "we should actually be thinking about" any number of inspired things related to the sacrament prayers. Quote
mikbone Posted November 30, 2018 Author Report Posted November 30, 2018 (edited) 48 minutes ago, CV75 said: Just a couple of tips: 1) testimony ends the exchange of ideas, which is what I find valuable about "Gospel Discussion"; 2) "we should actually be thinking about" any number of inspired things related to the sacrament prayers. I'm pretty circumspect about when I testify. And I stand by what I wrote. Can you picture Adam nonchalantly making that first sacrifice? How do you see it going down? And I know that we can think about anything we want to during the sacrament. I also know what the sacrament prayer says. And the words probably have meaning. Edited November 30, 2018 by mikbone Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.